Week 7 Dwarves vs Ogres
74K fans come to Brass Knuckle day to watch the Moria Balrogs win a squeaker against the Oldheim Ogres 1-0. The dwarves also outhit the Ogres 3-1.
There was a controversery which could have cost the Ogres the game, as Mr nastyman scooped up the ball and pushed it twice to deliver an ineffectual foul on a downed troll slayer. The ref spotted it by rolling a six and ejected him from the game.
Graeme, who was subbing for Dave K, said that he thought based on our rules that since Dirty Player gave a -1 modifier to being spotted, he could not be throw out (which is why he threw the foul). I did not let him redo his actions and the ball scattered.
Upon later reflection I was in error, and I should have allowed Graeme to take his action back.
Hindsight being 20/20, I don't think that this would have changed the final outcome as the Dwarves could do no wrong, and the ogres were hitting their opponents with fluffy pillows.
Moria Balrogs:
FF +1
Earnings +10K
Handicaps:
Inspiration (receive 2 MVPs 1 before game)
Winds of Change
#2 Albrecht +Mvp (before game), advances, ages, takes Tackle, gains Niggle
#4 Bomber +2 cas
#6 Oin Deathroller confiscated
#7 Gloin +Mvp
#8 Fili +cas
#10 Stumpy Killed by Phineas Freak
#14 Gimlet +cp, +TD, Advances, no age, SKILL
Old TR 221, new TR 207
Ogres
+0k
FF -1
Before match spend 20K to buy snotling (he was factor in the last three turns actually and was injured on turn 16).
#1 Rufus +cp
#2 Phieneas Phreak +cas
#8 Jerimah Grimm, +MVP, advances DOUBLES (block?), no age
#9 Snotling, SI, MNG gains Niggle
#10 Keynote, SI, MNG, -ST
#13 Wonderboy, SI MNG, gains Niggle
Old TR 250, new TR 250
There was a controversery which could have cost the Ogres the game, as Mr nastyman scooped up the ball and pushed it twice to deliver an ineffectual foul on a downed troll slayer. The ref spotted it by rolling a six and ejected him from the game.
Graeme, who was subbing for Dave K, said that he thought based on our rules that since Dirty Player gave a -1 modifier to being spotted, he could not be throw out (which is why he threw the foul). I did not let him redo his actions and the ball scattered.
Upon later reflection I was in error, and I should have allowed Graeme to take his action back.
Hindsight being 20/20, I don't think that this would have changed the final outcome as the Dwarves could do no wrong, and the ogres were hitting their opponents with fluffy pillows.
Moria Balrogs:
FF +1
Earnings +10K
Handicaps:
Inspiration (receive 2 MVPs 1 before game)
Winds of Change
#2 Albrecht +Mvp (before game), advances, ages, takes Tackle, gains Niggle
#4 Bomber +2 cas
#6 Oin Deathroller confiscated
#7 Gloin +Mvp
#8 Fili +cas
#10 Stumpy Killed by Phineas Freak
#14 Gimlet +cp, +TD, Advances, no age, SKILL
Old TR 221, new TR 207
Ogres
+0k
FF -1
Before match spend 20K to buy snotling (he was factor in the last three turns actually and was injured on turn 16).
#1 Rufus +cp
#2 Phieneas Phreak +cas
#8 Jerimah Grimm, +MVP, advances DOUBLES (block?), no age
#9 Snotling, SI, MNG gains Niggle
#10 Keynote, SI, MNG, -ST
#13 Wonderboy, SI MNG, gains Niggle
Old TR 250, new TR 250
posted by Thomas MacDevitt at
12:31 PM
2 Comments:
Good question.
Short answer, becuase its part of the post game sequence.
Long answer:
I roll for everything when I sub a game because I need to provide a report, and in the case where a game is late, I might have to sub play the same team again.
Also I have a witness right there to observe the rolls.
In addition therre have been cases where Ricardo and Dave might have lost out on Skills for a game because they forgot that they had advances, this method clears it up.
Finally, because thats how I did it in the past, but I can adopt whatever the group decides.
By
Thomas MacDevitt, at 2:53 PM
Graeme,
I'm of course projecting an outcome that would have led to that Goblin being BH in a 1 die dwarven blitz!
By
Thomas MacDevitt, at 5:37 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home